Kids respond to Xanga publicity

I had an interesting conversation with a reporter this evening on the phone. She called to ask about student podcasting, and we discussed different schools in our state (Texas) as well as around the country who are using podcasts in creative ways.

She told me an interesting story that happened about a year ago when she was writing for a different newspaper in another state. She wrote an article about Xanga and how students were using it for social networking, homework collaboration, and other things– as we’ve read other places most likely, some students were posting their cell phone numbers, IM addresses, and LOTS of personal info there which could potentially put them in danger.

As a result of the article, the reporter received MANY emails from teenagers both in the local area but also in other parts of the United States. Some were angry, others saw valid points in her article. Some were upset that as a result of her article, more parents were learning about social networking sites like Xanga and MySpace. These kids, apparently, wanted their activities online to remain a secret from the adults– at least the adults in their homes and schools.

We need all educational stakeholders: students, parents, teachers, principals and other community members, to be communicating better in general. On the topic of technology use specifically, there needs to be more communication about what students are doing, who they are communicating with, and what information they are sharing and accessing.

But we also need to be talking about the POSITIVE ways these technologies are being used and can be used to help students develop authentic literacy skills as well as problem solving skills. Hopefully we’ll see more mainstream news articles about the positive uses of student blogs, podcasts, and other web 2.0 technologies in the months and years to come.

These technology tools are potentially DISRUPTIVE to traditional communication methods because they fundamentally alter notions of audience and publisher. We need to leverage the constructive use of these tools in the 21st century classroom.

On this day..

  • http://www.blendededu.com Derek

    Amen Wesley!

    It’s interesting to sit back and watch the backlash against MySpace and other social networking sites. In fact, the other night the local news ran a “special report” on MySpace.

    They went through the usual (valid) issues about teens posting too much personal info and the potential dangers. They showed some of the MySpace pages and were careful to blur the faces on to “protect their identities.” Okay. Fine. Great.

    Next story is about elementary school kids doing some great project. The reporter shows the kids faces, names their school, and names the teacher. So now the reporter has potentially put those kids in just as much (or more) danger as the teens putting personal info on their MySpace page.

    Seems like there is a disconnect somewhere….I wonder if the news director saw the irony in these two stories? Old media vs. new? I don’t know. But I am tired of all the ratings motivated stories against social media. Perhaps because social media is new, it scares people.

    But like you pointed out, new ICT’s challenge the status quo and change is hard for people to accept.

  • http://www.wesfryer.com Wesley Fryer

    We have to keep in mind that Neil Postman was probably correct about the media when he wrote the book “Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business.” He pointed out that in the end, all news is about entertainment much more than it is about education. Now I am not sure if I’ll put CSPAN, A&E Biography, and some other programming from PBS in that boat, but for most news I think we sadly have to.

    You are right, it is up to us to help tell “the rest of the story,” as Paul Harvey loves to say. The contrast between those two news episodes that you saw side by side is VERY interesting. From a media literacy standpoint that certainly warrants analysis. I would guess the reporters were being more sensitive to the privacy issues in the myspace piece because of the child endangerment subject… but you’re certainly right in pointing out the contradiction the next news piece revealed.

© Creative Commons License