Join StoryChasers! StoryChasers - Empowering Responsible Digital Citizenship - Invent the future! Scratch | Home | imagine, program, share
26th February 2007

Sub-$100 digital audio recorders come to Wally world

posted in podcasting |

I was delighted to see the following three digital audio recorders available for purchase at a Missouri Wal-Mart somewhere between Oklahoma City and St Louis last night around 8 pm. (There are a lot of sub-$100 digital audio PLAYERS out there, but fewer that are RECORDERS supporting portable voice recording that is ideal for podcasting.)

Creative Zen V Plus 1GB MP3 Video Player:

Creative Zen at WalMart 2-25-2007

ilo MP3 player and recorder (couldn’t find this on walmart.com for some reason):

ilo at WalMart 2-25-2007

SanDisk Sansa c240 1GB Photo MP3 Player

Sansa at WalMart 2-25-2007:

Other sub-$100 digital recorders listed on the Wal-Mart website that I didn’t see in the store last night include:
- Philips SA4010 1GB Flash Digital Audio Player - $60
- Creative Zen Nano Plus 1 GB MP3 Player - $60

A few things to notice among these choices:
- The Sansa also supports photo playback.
- The Creative Zen supports both photo and video playback.
- All of these have 1 GB of storage. (That’s a lot for compressed audio!)
- None of these are Mac or Linux compatible.

Unless I’m missing something (and I don’t think I am, because I have been checking Wal-Mart for several weeks now looking for exactly these types of digital audio recorders) it seems like some sort of tipping point has been reached. This is the first time I’ve seen sub-$100 digital audio recorders in Wal-Mart that support transfer to a computer. Previously, the only ones I’d seen were by Memorex– and the ones that supported PC file transfer were all more than $100.

Online ordering is great, but for classroom teachers contemplating podcasting I think having products come down in price and be sold at Wal-Mart is an important thing. I regard my portable digital audio recording devices as the most important pieces of equipment I have for podcasting.

In the old west, the tool of the trade for every cowboy (at least the mythological ones we seem to believe in) was the six gun.

six shooter

I consider portable digital audio recorders to be essentials in my citizen journalist arsenal of “tools.” In my continuing quest for an inexpensive digital audio recorder for classroom teachers, my new favorite portable podcasting tool of choice is definitely the Samsung YP-U2J audio player.

Samsung YP-U2J audio player

No cables required or to lose, no batteries required, strong, clear audio pickup for voice recording and the simplicity of just plugging it into the USB drive of your computer make it my current recommendation for portable digital recording for classroom podcasters. (I bought one for our church this past weekend at Circuit City for $60.)

My biggest gripe is: All of these recorders (if the packaging on each of them can be believed) are ONLY compatible with Windows OS computers. :-( You’d think more computer manufacturers would realize there are now more viable choices than ever for computer operating systems, and products which function in multiple OS environments have a greater potential marketshare!

This is another example of “Windows-focused” thinking which still seems to drive many in both business and education. Despite this shortcoming, it is exciting to see that some sort of $100 tipping point for portable digital audio recorders seems to have been passed! If you have $60 or can talk your local PTA out of $60, there are few tools I can recommend more highly for classroom teachers interested in podcasting and digital storytelling than a portable digital audio recorder like one of these.

Technorati Tags:

On this day..

There are currently 6 responses to “Sub-$100 digital audio recorders come to Wally world”

Join the conversation!

  1. 1 On February 27th, 2007, Chris Craft said:

    Wes,

    I have been following your portable podcast recorder on-the-cheap discussion hoping for a good idea for one to get for myself. I have two questions about the Samsung you mention…

    1. How long can it record with 1 GB? I mean in terms of hours of voice into mp3.

    2. Does it have any support for an external mic? The samsung site is loading terribly so I can’t check there. How well does it record hanging from a necklace (a la Vicki Davis)?

    Thanks!

    Chris Craft

  2. 2 On February 27th, 2007, Wesley Fryer said:

    Chris: The battery life for the Samsung is rated at 2.5 hours. I haven’t tested this myself yet. For classroom recording use I think this is probably great. For field trip or edtech conference recording I am still preferring removable battery recorders. There is no support for an external mic with the Samsung. It has great pickup, however, and will work well hanging from a necklace. It doesn’t come with one, so I’m hunting for a necklace with an eyelet small enough to fit in it.

  3. 3 On February 28th, 2007, Scott Elias said:

    Wes -

    I think you’re a Mac guy, aren’t you? Would you be willing to post about what your podcasting setup looks like?

    Thanks!

    Scott

  4. 4 On February 28th, 2007, Wesley Fryer said:

    Scott: Unfortunately from my perspective (maybe fortunately from my wife’s) I don’t have a home or portable podcasting setup anything close to what Tim Wilson does for his podcave! I just use the built-in mic for most of my podcasts, except for the sessions I record with my iRiver. I would like to set up to a more sophisticated mic setup, but at this point haven’t! On the windows side, I use a $7 labtech mic from Walmart. I do most of my podcasts from my Macbook tho.

  5. 5 On March 1st, 2007, Scott Elias said:

    Thanks for the info and the link to Tim’s blog! I’ve been toying with interviewing some teachers who are trying some cool stuff with technology and posting it on our school’s site. I’ll check it out.

  6. 6 On March 14th, 2007, » Digital Storytelling from the Trenches said:

    [...] Tip #2 from the trenches: Somehow find a way to purchase several of the MP3 Voice Recorders so that students are not tied to a computer to record their narration. Wes Fryer has a great post about these devices on his blog. [...]