I presented a session on VoiceThread today for the “Survive and Thrive” 2008 Single Moms conference in Edmond, Oklahoma. My session was titled “Digital Storytelling with VoiceThread.” My earlier session in the day on “Internet Safety” was better attended, largely because I don’t think many of the moms attending the conference knew what “digital storytelling” is. With hindsight, I think I should have titled my session “Interactive Digital Scrapbooking” or “Safely Sharing Your Child’s Voice Online with Grandparents.”

As always, in preparing for this presentation I learned a great deal. I had previously read about VoiceThread offering downloadable archives (and had heard this was coming back in January during our Technology Shopping Cart podcast with the VoiceThread founders) but had never tried it before. I love it! With a Pro or free K-12 educator’s VoiceThread account you can export and download 30 different VoiceThreads. (Additional ones cost $2.99 each.)

VoiceThread - exported movie status

I found the export process speedy, and am SO glad this functionality is available! Previously I had used SnapzPro Pro X software to capture screencast movies of some of my VoiceThreads (and those of others in some cases, like the podcast version of Kevin Jarrett and Sylvia Martinez’ K12Online07 presentation in VoiceThread about Second Life) but found some problems with this method. First, it was time consuming. Second, if the local Internet connection was slow or there was an interruption in the playback of a comment, that interruption was captured in the screencast movie. This method of archiving VoiceThreads worked, but it wasn’t easy. Exporting VoiceThreads into archives on the site IS very simple and straightforward. My parents are the first beneficiaries of this… We created some private VoiceThreads for them in the past year as birthday and Mother’s Day gifts. Now they have their own offline copies of these precious stories told (principally) by our children!

The second VoiceThread feature about which I learned new things in getting ready for today’s presentation concerned comment moderation. Generally I think, as teachers, we tend to default to web publication arrangements for students (and perhaps our own children) which maximize control and conservatively limit the potential problems which could arise. By default, VoiceThread digital stories are private. If you choose to make a VoiceThread public, so it shows up in the “browse” tab of the main website, comment moderation is turned on by default. I hadn’t seen this warning previously, so it must be new, but now (I assume this is just for accounts flagged as “teacher accounts”) the following warning is displayed if you choose to turn OFF comment moderation:

VoiceThread - warning about comment moderation

Seeing this warning got me thinking about the most popular VoiceThread members of our family have created to date: Rachel’s “Getting a New HairCut” story. To date, this VoiceThread has been viewed over 8000 times worldwide:

Over 8000 VoiceThread views

That statistic is amazing, but I think the fact that we’ve had less than five total comments during that entire time which I have considered inappropriate or offensive is also noteworthy. In the four new comments I previewed and reviewed which had been added to this VoiceThread yesterday, there was one which fit into this “not nice” category:

One of the few negative comments on this unmoderated VoiceThread

The steps to get rid of this comment were very straightforward: I simply clicked on the comment and then DELETE IT:

VoiceThread comment moderation

It would be nice, perhaps, if no one left rude comments like this on public websites, but we all know (I would guess) that sort of idealism is extremely naive and unrealistic. Despite this fact, I’ve been glad to leave this particular VoiceThread set to “public” WITHOUT comment moderation because I think it has provided a good test case for a hypothesis I formed about VoiceThread commenting. When we initially published this, I guessed not many people would be rude and leave inappropriate comments. This was due in large part to Rachel’s age and the topic of her VoiceThread, but also due to the fact that I think most people listening to her story would choose to be kind rather than mean.

Our experiences with comment moderation and VoiceThread may be be unique, I’m not sure. I am encouraged by these experiences, however, and encourage others to experiment with public VoiceThreads which are unmoderated for comments. When it comes to STUDENT and CLASSROOM VoiceThreads and other digital stories, I definitely encourage comment moderation. It’s interesting to experiment with unmoderated digital stories like this, however, which are personally published. I’d be interested to hear what others’ experiences are with VoiceThread comments in this regard.

Technorati Tags:
, , , , ,


Did you know Wes has published 9 eBooks, and 1 of them is available free? Check them out!

Do you use a smartphone or tablet? Subscribe to Wes' free magazine "iReading" on Flipboard!


If you're trying to listen to a podcast episode and it's not working, check this status page. (Wes is migrating his podcasts to Amazon S3 for hosting.) Remember to follow Wesley Fryer on Twitter (@wfryer), Facebook and Google+. Also "like" Wesley's Facebook pages for "Speed of Creativity Learning" and his eBook, "Playing with Media." Don't miss Wesley's latest technology integration project, "Mapping Media to the Common Core / Curriculum."

On this day..

Share →
  • http://www.betchablog.com chris betcher

    Wes, I’ve had a similar experience with lack of inappropiate comments. I would generally set student voicethreads to be moderated but I have a number of personal voicethreads online and none of them have ever had silly or rude comments added to them.

    The only time I’ve had an inappropriate comment added was once one a Youtube video I made and that was just from someone who said they didn’t like my voice. Thats ok… I know where the delete key is.

    I think the whole poor taste and inappropriate comment thing is blown greatly out of proportion.

    Chris

  • http://www.mackieimages.com Mackie Images

    I agree with the last post. I have had very few experiences with inappropriate comments and because I receive an email informing me a comment has been made on my site, I can easily delete if need be. Chalk this up to another bout of fear with the internet and public perception.

    All that being said, if I were involved or responsible for managing a site within the educational/student realm, I would definitely consider it.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

Made with Love in Oklahoma City