Today I learned that over a year ago, one of our children was “banned” from the Club Penguin website for 24 hours for using profanity. I learned about this when I was checking out the “Ban History” on my Club Penguin “Parent Tools” page. Obviously that isn’t a “web history” page I visit very often.
This discovery led to some VERY good and important conversations with our child, even though the event itself took place over a year ago. I wrote a bit more about the theological aspects of these issues on the post on my Christian blog, “An Opportunity to Discuss Confession and Forgiveness.” In this post, I want to reflect briefly on the value of having digital documentation of online behavior in secular contexts.
Digital documentation is important. There are NOT any 100% safeguards that we can put into place, at home or at school, which can guarantee our children/students won’t encounter objectionable content online. There is a big different between “accidentally” encountering objectionable content and intentionally trying to find it. Plato’s parable about the “Ring of Gyges” is very relevant in this context. Our perceived level of anonymity/invisibility matters.
There are different ways to encourage perceptions of digital/online accountability for students at school in 1:1 laptop settings, including random ARD screen checks as well as laptop hard drive inspections. It’s important to have ways of remaining digitally accountable at home, too. My wife regularly looks at the text message history of both our kids who have cell phones, and this has led to many good conversations as well. Of course it’s possible for a child/individual to delete a conversation, erase web history, use an “incognito” browser window, change DNS settings to bypass OpenDNS at home, or do other things to circumvent accountability measures. If kids want to get around accountability measures to access digital content we don’t want them to see/view, chances are VERY high today they can find ways to do it.
Given these facts, I continue to maintain that open/regular communication is the KEY. Digital documentation, like that provided by the Club Penguin “Parent Tools” features, helps.
If you don’t currently use OpenDNS (which is free) on your home Internet connection, I strongly encourage you to check it out. In the past, the records it keeps of blocked website domains have been VERY valuable in our home for the same reasons the Club Penguin Parent Page resources were today. They can provide documentation of online behavior which otherwise might remain hidden and therefore “undiscussed” between members of our family.
Internet filtering tools tend to be employed in far too conservative ways in many public schools today, unfortunately. My awareness of those issues and desire to constructively advocate about them encouraged me to start the “Unmasking the Digital Truth” project several years ago, along with the Balanced Filtering Project. I hope to expand and further develop those initiatives in the months ahead.
I’m an advocate for BALANCED Internet filtering, both at home and at school. I’ve experienced the value of having some ROUTER BASED content filtering in place several times in the past decade. See my March 2008 post, “The Value of OpenDNS (free) content filtering at home” for an example.
In writing this post, I just checked our OpenDNS blocked domains log, and plan to have a conversation with at least one member of our family tomorrow about some of what I saw. OpenDNS at this point doesn’t give information as detailed as “this device accessed this blocked website at this date/time,” but it does provide enough information to start a conversation.
Eventually, I’d like to see schools provide access to web history and blocked/banned website access on the school content filter on the same interface parents use to see student grades. Given the pace of the typical K-12 school in addressing digital citizenship issues, however, I’d guess we’re several decades away from seeing that kind of thing as commonplace. Internet access options like cell phone tethering and cell network hotspots are changing these dynamics, however, especially in urban areas where higher speed cell networks are in place. There are no panaceas, but there ARE tools which facilitate opportunities for good conversations about Internet safety and ethics.
I think we all need to adopt a “defense in depth” strategy, which is a term I heard at a Microsoft Internet security workshop about eight years ago I attended at Texas Tech. There isn’t a single strategy that is going to protect your network from Internet threats, anymore than there is a single approach which is going to guarantee your child will make good choices online as an ethical and responsible free agent. Conversations and open communication are the key.
For additional resources and ideas along these lines, check out these past posts:
- Internet Safety and Digital Citizenship Presentations for Students, Parents and Teachers (August 2010)
- MinistrySafe Online Video Training for Youth Protection from Sexual Abuse (January 2012)
- Webcam and PSP Porn: More reasons for ongoing digital dialog (July 2008)
Did you know Wes has published 9 eBooks, and 1 of them is available free? Check them out! Do you use a smartphone or tablet? Subscribe to Wes' free magazine "iReading" on Flipboard!
If you're trying to listen to a podcast episode and it's not working, check this status page. (Wes is migrating his podcasts to Amazon S3 for hosting.) Remember to follow Wesley Fryer on Twitter (@wfryer), Facebook and Google+. Also "like" Wesley's Facebook pages for "Speed of Creativity Learning" and his eBook, "Playing with Media." Don't miss Wesley's latest technology integration project, "Mapping Media to the Curriculum."
On this day..
- No-Edit Audio Podcasting Videoconference (referenced links) - 2014
- Brookstone Mini-Projector for iPhone4 - 2012
- All bloggers are not scrape blog pirates - 2011
- High Stakes Testing Must End in the USA - 2011
- Local Advocacy Update in Alabama by Bruce Ellard - 2011
- 2011 Alabama Legislative Session Update (10 March) - 2011
- Oklahoma City Podcasting Club - March 2010 Meeting Notes - 2010
- A professor who takes laptop banning too far - 2010
- The Race to Nowhere - A New Educational Documentary - 2010
- Imagineering iPad Educational Apps - 2010